|  
For
more than five years the Cosmic Background Imager has had the vast, high
Chajnantor plateau virtually all to itself. The clamshell dome is made
of sailcloth, flexible enough to withstand 100-mph winds; when it opens,
the CBI can train its 13 antennas (right, in their original configuration)
on the microwave background radiation, emitted 400,000 years after the
Big Bang. Recent polarization experiments on the tiny temperature fluctuations
in this radiation have revealed primordial matter bunching into the seeds
of our present-day galaxies.
From its
high, dry site on the Llano de Chajnantor in Chile’s Atacama Desert,
the Cosmic Background Imager (CBI) peers back 13.8 billion years, searching
for tiny fluctuations in temperature encrypted on the microwave background
radiation, the fossil radiation left over from the birth of the cosmos.
That radiation, the most ancient light in the universe, was emitted just
400,000 years after the Big Bang (the equivalent of about 45 minutes after
conception when compared to a human life). It’s the epoch when light
and matter decoupled, when protons and electrons got together to form
atoms, so that the electrons stopped scattering photons, freeing them
to travel across time and space into the CBI’s antennas. Tony Readhead
finds it “miraculous.” You go up there with this instrument,
and you’re collecting photons that haven’t interacted with
anything for the last 13.8 billion years.”
Those collected
photons gave Readhead and his colleagues the first glimpse, in January
2000, of primordial matter beginning its collapse into the clumps that
would eventually evolve into clusters of galaxies. More recently, polarization
observations have revealed the dynamics of that clumping—data just
published last fall.
Plucking
13.8-billion-year-old photons out of the sky is not, obviously, an easy
task. Llano de Chajnantor, at 5,080 meters (16,700 feet) in the driest
place on Earth, looked to be an ideal place from which to attempt to see
this ancient light. The area was first explored in 1994 by a combined
team from the American NRAO (National Radio Astronomy Observatory) and
the University of Chile Astronomy Department, prompted by earlier measurements
of the atmospheric opacity obtained by a team of Japanese astronomers
in the nearby highlands. In that year the NRAO put up a test site, getting
“incredible” results. “It’s the best easily accessible
site in the world for radio astronomy,” Readhead, the Rawn Professor
of Astronomy and the CBI’s principal investigator, claims, with
at least 330 observing days annually and almost no moisture to interfere
with the incoming radio waves. “Easily accessible” may be
in the eye of the beholder, but Readhead and his optimistic team were
the first to seize the opportunity to build an observatory there, with
a little help from some new Chilean friends—not just other astronomers,
but also a lawyer and a landowner.
Chile’s
high, dark expanses with exposure to the southern sky and unrivaled “seeing”
have lured foreign astronomers for decades, and the nation has always
welcomed the astronomers and tried to make it comfortable for them to
come. Numerous American, European, and, lately, Japanese telescopes dot
the lengthy Andean range. While most of these observatories are located
within logistical reach of Santiago or at least another city, Readhead’s
coveted site lay in the remote northern desert near the Bolivian border,
where virtually nothing grows and few human artifacts existed.
“Pioneers
have all the fun,” Readhead now says, somewhat wryly, remembering
the myriad problems. His was a comparatively small operation—just
himself and a handful of Caltech postdocs, research faculty, members of
the professional staff, and grad students—without the enormous resources
of the larger astronomical communities, many with government backing.
This was not Big Science, by any means. Readhead had started designing
the CBI in 1987, working on key aspects of the architecture with Charles
Lawrence at JPL, grad student Steve Myers, and several Caltech undergraduates
in the early ’90s; then he, Steve Padin, member of the professional
staff, and engineer Walt Schaal (BS ’58) proceeded with the detailed
design in 1993 (E&S, 1996, No. 4). It was initially funded jointly
in 1995 by the National Science Foundation, a generous gift from Maxine
and Ronald Linde and funds from the Provost’s Office, and was built
at Caltech next to the cogeneration power plant’s cooling towers
on Holliston Avenue.
But before
tackling the logistical problems of importing a telescope to Chile and
hauling it up a remote mountain, first the legal issues had to be faced.
The Santiago branch of a large American law firm proved both expensive
and ineffective. In June 1997, however, at the NRAO in Charlottesville,
Virginia, Readhead met with Leonardo Bronfman, former chair of the University
of Chile astronomy department and member of the Chajnantor exploration
team, who offered the support and collaboration of his department and
pointed out a unique law that enabled foreign astronomical institutions
affiliated with that university to bring instruments into the country
free of the 35 percent import duty and to operate without paying the 19
percent sales tax. Subsequently, Readhead was introduced to Juan Enrique
Ruiz, a lawyer at the university who was experienced in helping foreigners
set up complex technological enterprises in Chile. Ruiz, along with Bronfman
and Jorge May, a radio astronomer at the University of Chile, smoothly
guided the Caltech group over the bureaucratic hurdles and through the
paperwork—“all the stuff we didn’t have a clue about
how to do,” says Readhead. For example, they helped him obtain the
official permission to install the CBI at the Chajnantor site, a science
preserve then administered by the Chilean Consejo Nacional de Investigación
Científica y Tecnológica, which was also very supportive.
Ruiz remains a loyal friend of the project and still helps out—most
recently with new generator contracts—largely out of good will rather
than for a hefty fee.
The Chajnantor
site is remote, but there is a pleasant village 40 kilometers away and
about 2,500 meters lower. An oasis frequented by pre-Columbian inhabitants,
the town of San Pedro de Atacama was founded by conquistadors in the 16th
century and remains popular with tourists who love the desert, particularly
Europeans. It doesn’t have paved roads, but it does have a couple
of decent restaurants and a handful of hotels. Because the CBI was originally
planned as a two-year project, it didn’t make any sense to buy or
build a permanent place to stay, but the astronomers would have to sleep
somewhere. While the CBI construction was finishing up in Pasadena, Readhead
was scouting his Atacama site, where Angel Otarola of the European Southern
Observatory (ESO) helped him get set up and happened to introduce him
to Don Tomás Poblete, who owned a fruit farm near Santiago. (In
the early 1900s, Poblete’s father had emigrated at the age of 12
from southern to northern Chile, newly acquired from Peru and Bolivia,
and made his fortune selling produce to the mining companies.) Poblete
never lost his love of the northern desert and had built a home in San
Pedro de Atacama—and a comfortable adobe hotel on his property.
“In
a country of charming people, Don Tomás and his wife, Milka, and
son, Jorge, are five standard deviations above,” says Readhead.
Poblete offered to build an apartment for the Caltech astronomers at his
hotel. When he unveiled the CBI headquarters (five bedrooms, two computer
rooms, and a kitchen) in August 1999, “it was fantastic,”
says Readhead. It was half again as big as had been contracted for, and
“every room was a bigger surprise. Don Tomás told us he asked
himself ‘What would I want if I were to stay here for two years?
And this is what I’ve built for you.’”
When a few
local people (impossible to put on the distant Caltech payroll) needed
to be hired, Poblete took them on as employees of his hotel. The Casa
de Don Tomás is probably the only hotel in the world with telescope
technicians on its payroll. Poblete remains close to the project and still
showers the astronomers with hospitality and assistance. “San Pedro
is the last dream of my life,” says Poblete, who believes that what
the astronomers have brought, especially knowledge, is good for the village.
“Your dreams are my dreams,” he told them.
The Cosmic
Background Imager was crated up to leave Caltech in July 1999, arriving
in Chile in August. By October, the telescope was at the site, snug inside
its dome, its generators humming (sometimes). By January it was ready
to go to work.

The CBI is
a millimeter-wavelength radio interferometer, the first in Chile, and
consists of 13 antennas arrayed on a platform 6 meters in diameter. Each
0.9-meter antenna has its own receiver, sheltered by a shield can to prevent
cross talk from leaking between its neighbors. Although it’s tiny
compared to the 40-meter antenna at Caltech’s Owens Valley Radio
Observatory (OVRO), “it’s a very powerful instrument,”
says Readhead, 75 times more sensitive than the 40-meter for this particular
kind of work. Each of the 13 antennas can be paired with any of the 12
others, and the signals from the 78 possible pairs at 10 different frequencies
multiplied and correlated to act as an array of 780 interferometers.
Steve Padin,
the team’s chief scientist, designed the complex correlator (which
correlates the signals from each pair forming an interferometer) and much
of the other instrumentation. Readhead describes him as a “world-class
instrumentalist” and calls Tim Pearson, senior research associate,
who was responsible for the data-reduction and analysis software, “one
of the best writers of astronomical software in the world.” Also
among the original group were staff scientist Martin Shepherd, “a
truly outstanding programmer,” who designed the computer-control
and data-acquisition systems; John Cartwright (PhD ’03), who built
the amplifiers that determine the telescope’s sensitivity and carried
out pioneering polarization observations for his thesis; grad students
Jonathan Sievers (PhD ’04) and Patricia Udomprasert (PhD ’04);
and engineers Walt Schaal and John Yamasaki.
Because the
receivers need to be kept at about -450° F (6 K, or degrees above
absolute zero), closed-cycle helium refrigerators are an essential part
of the design and a continual challenge to maintain. When a “fridge”
breaks down, you can’t just call in someone from Atacama Appliance
Repair. In the first years, the fridges were sent all the way back to
the U. S. for maintenance, but now the local technicians and grad students,
equipped with the equivalent of a private machine shop and hardware store
(from nails and screwdrivers to replacement parts) do most of the repairs
on the site.
Why do the
receivers have to be so cold? They’re trying to detect temperature
differences of only millionths of a degree (or microkelvins), which indicate
density differences in the microwave background radiation. The microwave
background was discovered accidentally in 1965 by Arno Penzias and Robert
Wilson (PhD ’62) of Bell Labs, and was seen as proof that the Big
Bang theory of the universe, which predicted such radiation, was correct.
Since then, astronomers and physicists have been training their sights
on it, with ever more sensitive and sophisticated instruments, to tease
out cosmological clues about the embryonic universe—how galaxies
and stars were born. Using OVRO’s 40-meter telescope in the 1980s,
Readhead saw no temperature fluctuations in the microwave background.
After writing a paper in 1989 showing that this implied that galaxies
would not have had sufficient time to condense unless most of the matter
in the universe were “dark matter,” he was teased for proving
that we didn’t exist. Then the COBE (Cosmic Background Explorer)
satellite, launched in 1989, became the first to show that the background
temperature was not uniform, confirming what had been suspected—that
inscribed on the radiation is the cosmic DNA that spells out how galaxies
were conceived, as well as such fundamental cosmological parameters as
the size, age, and geometry of the universe.
But the Big
Bang theory still presented a bunch of problems: Why did the universe
expand? Is the expansion accelerating or decelerating? How can it be so
uniform in all directions when its components can’t communicate
because their separation is greater than the time it takes light to travel
between them? Inflation theory, which proposes a massive expansion in
the first fraction of a second after the Big Bang, offers solutions to
these problems. “It may not be true, of course,” says Readhead,
but data from the CBI and other instruments so far appear to buttress
the predictions of an inflationary universe.
One of those
predictions is that the universe is very nearly “flat”—not
flat in the sense of a pancake, but flat in the sense of Euclidian space
in which two parallel lines will never converge or diverge, so that the
universe will expand forever. This prediction was proven true a few years
ago by Andrew Lange, the Goldberger Professor of Physics, whose BOOMERANG
experiment observed the microwave background from a balloon high above
Antarctica (E&S, 2000, No. 3). BOOM-ERANG’s picture of the microwave
background radiation also showed differences in density in much finer
detail than that of COBE’s map, which resolved features in the sky
the size of 14 moon diameters. Lange’s detectors could see structures
the size of 0.5 moon diameters.
The CBI,
however, has much finer resolution still; its most widely separated pairs
of antennas can resolve details as small as 0.1 moon diameters. The first
CBI data provided independent confirmation of the almost “flat”
universe, but what was more remarkable were its pictures of the seeds
from which all structures in the universe eventually evolved beginning
to condense out of the primordial soup. On the CBI’s first night
of observation, January 11, 2000, “we actually saw the seeds of
galaxies for the first time,” says Readhead. “We saw what
it would have looked like.” (Even though this is a radio telescope,
the astronomers are seeing what human eyes would have seen. The radiation
has been redshifted and stretched to the longer wavelengths of radio waves,
but when the photons were emitted, they were the shorter wavelengths of
light photons.)

Even
rugged four-wheel-drive trucks can find it rough going in the desert or
on the rudimentary Atacama roads. And sometimes, when the roads are impassable,
a little tow from a friend is welcome.
Seeing the
microwave background in such fine resolution made up for the hassles that
are inevitable when operating at an unsupported remote site. The power
generators have been challenging to maintain in conditions where the temperature
can drop to –20° C with winds of over 50 miles per hour and
blizzards occur a few times each year. So a lot of effort has to be expended
on maintaining infrastructure. “We’ve had 12 or 15 total losses
of power over the five years of operation,” says Readhead, “and
each time that happens, all 13 of our cryosystems warm up. Although it’s
clearly not the case, it sometimes feels as though keeping things running
is as big a challenge as doing the actual experiment.”
“Some
people think that astronomy is something that’s romantic and fun—looking
at the stars at night, you know, and that’s it,” says optical
astronomer Maria Teresa Ruiz, chair of the astronomy department at the
University of Chile, whose enthusiastic help has been essential to keeping
the CBI running. “Most of the work is not like that. Most of it
is hard work, some boring parts, and you have to endure that and have
enough inspiration to get you over that so you can get to the fun part.”
Radio astronomers
in particular have a hands-on culture. Readhead recalls his early days
at the University of Cambridge, when renowned astronomer Martin Ryle,
who later won the Nobel Prize, invited the young grad student to visit
the new One-Mile Telescope. “It was pouring rain. We went down to
this basement full of electronics, and water was pouring in. So he turned
around and said, ‘Come on.’ We went up to a little shed, and
he picked up a pick and handed me a shovel, and we started digging a storm-water
drain right then and there. It was hard work, and after about half an
hour or so picking and shoveling away in the rain, he turned to me and
said emphatically, ‘This is radio astronomy.’”
Floods aren’t
exactly a problem in the Atacama Desert, but snow and blizzards at the
high altitudes are, and the CBI’s sturdy four-wheel-drive pickups,
which are more at home in this challenging terrain than in Beverly Hills,
have often had to abandon the unplowed roads and take their chances navigating
boulder fields. Trucks usually travel in twos in snow conditions, since
one must always be prepared to tow the other out. Readhead tells a story
of four trucks once getting stuck in the snow before a rescue mission
succeeded.
Trucks weren’t
the only thing to get stuck. “The first blizzard we had up there,
the generators stopped, and we couldn’t get up to the site for three
days. By the time we got through, there was no longer any evidence as
to why the generators stopped because everything was melting by then.”
So when the next blizzard hit on a late afternoon, Readhead and Padin
jumped into a couple of trucks and headed up to the telescope to figure
out why the generators stopped when it snowed. “The last few kilometers
were almost total whiteout, and for the next 24 hours it was a continual
blizzard. What we found was that the air filter was getting filled with
snow, which then turned to ice, and that the generators had failed because
the air filters got clogged with ice. For the next 24 hours (we didn’t
sleep all night and the next day), we went out to the generators—130
meters from the control room—every hour. It turned out that 130
meters is a long way in a whiteout; we were both very glad that there
were two of us up there, because you had to be darned careful that you
didn’t wander off in a random direction. We would take out the air
filter, put in a new one, take the other one back and leave it next to
our chillers, which put out a lot of heat. We’d thaw it for an hour
or so and shake out all the ice and take it back to the generator. It
was blowing and it was incredibly cold.
“Finally
Steve figured out that we should block off the main air intake so the
air would be drawn into the secondary air intake that passed over various
parts of the generator, which would melt the snow before it got to the
air filter. We got big sheets of cardboard to put over the primary air
filters, but we had to tie them onto the grills because the wind was blowing
like crazy. We had our oxygen of course, which was essential. You could
just about tie one knot before your fingers got too frozen to tie the
next knot. So we were alternating—he would tie one knot while I
held the flashlight and then we’d switch. We finally got the cardboard
over the air filter and that solved the problem. Then we were snowed in
for three days. But it’s very safe up there as long as you’ve
got power, oxygen, food, water, and heat.”
Doing any
kind of work at 16,700 feet requires portable oxygen packs, such as emphysema
patients carry, and the CBI crew doesn’t hesitate to use them while
doing anything requiring physical exertion outside or in the dome, which
is open to the thin air. The shipping containers that serve as lab, control
room, and sleeping quarters for two have enhanced oxygen, that is, enhanced
to the level of oxygen at about 10,400 feet. Lack of oxygen affects one’s
thinking, and when they realize that their sentences are making no sense,
the astronomers reach for their oxygen tanks or head indoors.
For the first
two years, either Readhead or Padin was always at the site, with alternating
shifts of recruits from Pasadena. Two years is a long time in the desert,
where the living is not easy, and most of the original staff wanted to
go home. And the experiment was originally supposed to be over in two
years anyway. But Readhead wasn’t done yet; he had much more that
he wanted to see out there, and he thought the CBI was still the perfect
instrument to see it with and Chajnantor the best place to see it from.
At the South Pole, its sister instrument, DASI (Degree Angular Scale Interferometer—a
smaller version of the same design, with most key hardware and software
elements duplicated from the CBI blueprints), was looking for, and had
found, polarization in the microwave background radiation, another feature
predicted by inflation theory. If inflation is correct, the cosmic microwave
background would have been polarized as light and matter were decoupling,
when some electrons were still scattering some photons. Viewing the tiny
differences in temperature between light waves aligned in different directions
(anisotropies) gives astronomers an idea of the dynamics of matter in
the epoch of the microwave background.
John Kovac
of the DASI group (under John Carlstrom at the University of Chicago,
who, as associate professor of astronomy at Caltech had worked with Readhead
in the CBI’s early days) had developed some “superb”
polarizers, which would also be available to the CBI, now about to be
virtually orphaned in the desert. Readhead passionately wanted to look
for polarization at the CBI’s smaller angular scales and superior
site. The Kavli Foundation was interested in supporting the polarization
upgrade, but what about staffing? “Then Jorge found us these fantastic
engineers,” he said.
“Tony
was complaining that it was very expensive running the CBI, and I said,
‘Why don’t you hire Chilean engineers?’” said
Jorge May, a radio astronomy professor at the University of Chile, who
was among the discoverers of the Atacama site. Specifically he meant engineering
students, a solution that turned out to benefit all parties. “It’s
good for our economy,” said Maria Teresa Ruiz. “We don’t
have a lot of technology development in Chile. The CBI is on a very modest
scale, but these guys who work with Tony on this instrument—they
really are working with technology that is at the edge of what’s
now being developed. And I’m sure eventually they will be able to
do things in Chile for companies in different areas of the Chilean economy.
Being trained in forefront technology is very important—the way
of thinking about things, finding your own solutions. It’s that
kind of thinking that we need for our country.
“Only
the inspirational part of astronomy gets to the general public and to
the government,” Ruiz continued. “It’s not like in biology
where you can discover things that are worth money. Other sciences—they
all have this practical aspect. There are no patents to be had in astronomy.
But what many people have not realized is that there’s a lot of
technological development that goes on—spinoffs—that can be
applied to things that involve some money.”
May, who
had been an engineer before becoming a radio astronomer, first recommended
Pablo Altamirano, an electrical engineering grad student at the University
of Chile. In addition, the University of Concepción was particularly
open to the idea of a radio astronomy program within the engineering department,
and Ricardo Bustos switched from the University of Chile to the University
of Concepción for his PhD on the CBI.
“They’re
absolutely superb at diagnosing problems and then fixing them,”
boasts Readhead. The two Chilean students, later joined by another two
(Cristobal Achermann and Rodrigo Reeves), performed the polarization upgrade
on the CBI, which involved dismantling the 13 receivers, rewiring everything,
and reconfiguring the antennas—moving them from the perimeter to
an array (with six adjusted to right-hand circularly polarized radiation
and seven to left-hand) in the center of the platform, so closely packed
that the engineers and technicians had to become contortionists to get
to them. “If the central receiver fails, the only way you can get
to it is by worming your way up this cable rack,” says Readhead,
who isn’t eager to try it himself unless he has to. “And if
you do the wrong thing you can easily short out the cooling system. Then
you’ve blown everything—you’ve got 13 receivers that
are warming up and you’ve got a big problem on your hands.”
Recruiting
the Chilean grad students had one unintended consequence. “Tony
is so inspiring for these guys,” says Ruiz. “These are engineers.
But after a year of working with Tony, they all want to be astronomers.
They’re so important for the project, but now they all want to get
PhDs in astronomy. That’s his fault; he shouldn’t be so inspiring.”
Still, Achermann
and Reeves are sticking closer to engineering and writing dissertations
on the instrumentation that they helped develop for the CBI. Currently,
the two are alternating time slots for running the telescope—three
weeks at Chajnantor and two weeks back at the university. At Chajnantor,
they’re completely in charge of the project and of running the site.
“It’s a tremendous responsibility,” says Readhead. With
help from the San Pedro technicians, they maintain the telescope, including
troubleshooting (“I feel like a SWAT team,” says Achermann,
who describes the telescope as “like a big toy.”), and do
all the observing as well—the fun part. Another electrical engineering
student, Nolberto Oyarce, is the most recent team recruit.
“There’s
no way we could have done it without them,” says Readhead, but the
University of Chile has also benefited from this unique arrangement with
Caltech. From the beginning, its astronomers have had access to 10 percent
of the observing time on the CBI and have been coauthors on most of the
CBI papers. The instrument has been ideal for teaching radio astronomy,
and students, including undergraduates, have worked there in the summer,
collecting and analyzing data. The university had been trying to figure
out how to train engineers and technicians to staff all the new foreign
telescopes about to arrive in Chile, and the CBI has provided a perfect
model, according to Ruiz. Just last spring, the university established
a new PhD program in electrical engineering with a major in astronomical
instrumentation—a direct spinoff from the CBI project. And that’s
all in addition to the know-how the students are gaining by working with
the polarizers.
With the
polarizing upgrade complete, observations began in September 2002. But
the search for polarized light—finding anisotropies in already incredibly
small temperature fluctuations (smaller by a factor of 10 than previous
observations)—took a dogged 300 nights of observing (in contrast
to the eureka moment of CBI’s first night). Just as polarizing sunglasses
transmit only the light that is aligned with the glasses, the CBI’s
polarizers pick out only the polarized light from the total intensity
(including unpolarized radiation). The team observed four patches of sky,
all together an area about 300 times the size of the moon. By April 2004,
the data were complete enough for the team to be confident that they had
indeed seen polarized light, evidence of how the matter condensing into
galaxies is actually moving. Published in October 2004 as the cover article
in Science, the work confirms DASI’s results and extends
them to the higher resolution that can actually see the galaxy clusters.
The CBI data also shows that the polarization signal is out of step with
the total intensity signal—that is, the peaks of the polarized signal
correspond to the valleys of the total signal and vice versa—a sure
indication of the motion of the primordial plasma as it falls into the
seeds of galaxy clusters, confirming one of the basic predictions of the
theory.

These
recent images cover a patch of sky about 2.5 x 5 degrees, one of four
areas the CBI observed between 2002 and 2004. The left-hand image shows
the total intensity (unpolarized radiation) of the microwave background
signal. The other two images of the same patch map the radiation polarized
vertically (center) and at 45° (right) and show that it is much weaker
than the total intensity—about 10 percent of it. The polarization
signal is also contaminated by noise from the telescope itself, so the
CBI astronomers must use statistical analysis to extract the polarization
information. (Reprinted with permission from A.C.S. Readhead et al., Science,
vol. 306, no. 5697, 836-844, © 2004 AAAS.)
Cooperation
with other experiments will be essential as the observations become orders
of magnitude more difficult. Readhead predicts that what the CBI is doing
with its sister instruments is going to lead to a revolution in fundamental
physics. Cosmology and particle physics have come together, he claims,
cosmology providing the “laboratory” for high energies unattainable
in earthly accelerators. “And whenever two scientific disciplines
come together and find they have common ground, you get incredibly interesting
things going on at the interface,” he says.
Things like
dark matter. What Readhead is seeing is fluctuations in the dark matter
itself—nonbaryonic stuff that is not made up of protons and neutrons,
as is all the matter we can see around us. Nonbaryonic matter, which is
thought to account for about 22 percent of the energy of the universe
(dark energy makes up another 74 percent) would have the much larger density
fluctuations necessary to form galaxies in the billion years or so it
took to form them. But, because it doesn’t interact so strongly
with light, it produces the small temperature fluctuations in the microwave
background on the scale of galaxy clusters—implied by OVRO’s
40-meter telescope back in the 1980s (when Readhead “proved that
we don’t exist”) and finally seen for the first time by the
CBI. Readhead describes the ordinary matter of the galaxies as collapsing
into “wells” in the dark matter. “So it looks to us
as if galaxies are isolated,” says Readhead, “but the stuff
that has really formed them and caused them to be there is all around
them, still touching,” even though we can’t see it now. He’s
hoping new detectors will enable him to see it more clearly then.
A new type
of detector, called MMIC (Monolithic Millimeter-Wave Integrated Circuit)
Arrays, is being developed at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory by Todd Gaier,
Charles Lawrence, and Mike Seif-fert, and will be installed in a new experiment
on the CBI platform, called QUIET, for Q/U Imaging ExperimenT. The 1,000-element
array, the first radio “cameras,” which will improve the CBI’s
sensitivity to a fraction of a tenth of a microkelvin, should be ready
in 2006. A second string to QUIET will be the importation of a new 7-meter
telescope to complement the range of angular scales observed with the
upgraded CBI. Readhead, who considers himself lucky to be working at a
time when so much new technology is constantly coming on line, likens
it to a new window that has opened. “You don’t know what you’re
going to see through that new window,” he says, which is exciting
to an astronomer but hard to explain to funding agencies.
Readhead
is hoping for NSF funding next year for QUIET and hopes to make the Chajnantor
Observatory a permanent Caltech facility. While the project has received
most of its support from NSF, more than 40 percent has come from Caltech.
Besides the two Chilean universities, the Canadian Institute for Advanced
Research, the Kavli Institute for Cosmological Physics at the University
of Chicago, and the National Radio Astronomy Observatory have collaborated
on the CBI. In addition to the Lindes’ founding gift, Cecil and
Sally Drinkward gave to the project, and continuing support has come from
Barbara and Stanley Rawn, Jr. The Rawns most recently have provided funds
for a Caltech graduate student and a postdoc; Clive Dickinson (the most
recent recipient of the Michael Penston Prize for the best astronomy or
astrophysics thesis in the United Kingdom) arrived last summer from the
University of Manchester to take up the latter post. And some members
of the Associates on a President’s Circle trip to Chile last year,
were so impressed with the CBI’s well-run organization (as well
as with the science) that they offered substantial contributions on the
spot.
The Cosmic
Background Imager is no longer alone on the Chajnantor plain. ASTE (Atacama
Submillimeter Telescope Experiment) arrived at the Pampa la Bola, just
below Chajnantor, in 2002, and its Japanese scientists are now sharing
Don Tomás’s suite with the diminished Caltech crew (although
the fastidious Japanese maintain their own pristine refrigerator, separate
from the sloppier American/Chilean group). APEX (Atacama Pathfinder Experiment),
a German-built antenna, is just coming into operation. A Caltech/JPL/Cornell
collaboration is surveying a nearby peak as a site for a 25-meter submillimeter
antenna, as is Princeton for ACT (Atacama Cosmological Telescope).
But what
will alter the landscape the most is ALMA (Atacama Large Millimeter Array),
a massive American-European-Japanese undertaking, scheduled to join the
CBI in 2008. No less than 68 twelve-meter telescopes (plus 12 seven-meter
ones), of which APEX is a prototype, will mushroom across Chajnantor.
There will be a paved road (ALMA has already graded a better dirt road
across the plain) and a reliable source of power; Readhead’s Chilean
proteges will have plenty of job opportunities; and the astronomers in
San Pedro de Atacama may well outnumber the tourists and the ubiquitous
local dogs.
Ruiz and
some ALMA staff met not long ago with some of the local farmers and villagers
about the changes that are coming. “I gave them a talk,” she
says, “the same talk I give to the general public about the evolution
of the universe, with pictures and everything. And then representatives
from ALMA gave short talks about what they would do there—how they
would operate and how they would create new jobs, because they will need
people to clean and cook and things like that. So then came the question
time. And this guy raised his hand and he said, ‘More jobs is very
good news because we need jobs in this area, but it is not the most important
thing. The most important thing for us is our kids, and we would like
to know how you can help us get a better education for them so that they
can become astronomers and do all of these discoveries that this lady
is telling us about.’ I thought that was fantastic,” says
Ruiz.
Readhead
hopes that CBI/QUIET will still be there, probing the cosmic background
radiation for more clues to the nature of dark matter and dark energy
and also, as the instrument’s sensitivity increases, opening up
new areas of study in the radiation from our own galaxy. He and his collaborators
have already discovered a new form of “anomalous” galactic
emission that is not understood, and he already has plans for what should
come next.
Throughout
the CBI’s existence, Caltech’s president, provost, and the
division chair of physics, mathematics and astronomy have supported it
strongly. Recently, new collaborations with the Jet Propulsion Laboratory,
with the English universities of Oxford and Manchester, and with the Max
Planck Institute for Radio Astronomy in Bonn have brought additional support,
as well as ideas for novel instrumentation. A lot remains to be learned
from the cosmic background radiation, and this ground-based site can accommodate
larger, cheaper instruments than can be launched into space, such as European
Space Agency’s Planck satellite, scheduled for 2008.
The future
of the observatory will depend on continued innovation in a very competitive
field, as well as continued support from NSF and generous private donors,
but Readhead is confident that the importance and excitement of the science,
the potential of the new instrumentation, and the extraordinary quality
of the atmosphere at the site will ensure its survival.
Readhead
remembers what it was like as the lone settler on Chajnantor. “It’s
wonderfully romantic when you’re the only one on that site and you’re
up there observing,” says Readhead. “That’s one of the
things I like the most—to be up there observing on my own.”
Life will be much easier now (easy might trump romantic), and Readhead
welcomes all his imminent new neighbors, as the CBI continues to push
the latest technological developments to the limits of what is achievable
from the ground.
|